jadepaladin

Well-Known Member
Mar 9, 2020
1,226
2,485
He already did a decade of training without his powers. Even in the most basic military in the world - if you haven't figured out how to fight after 10 years of training, they either show you the door or find you a desk job.
Except he's not in any military being trained. He's a self taught adventurer that comes with all of the bad habits of being self taught. He have been dead long ago if not for his mentor and his powers. Diana should have been a humbling experience but like Mav said, actual character growth gets in the way when you've got women to collect. I know that last part doesn't apply to you, Pix, but it needs to be said all the same.

He barely eeks out a victory against Diana and instead of reflecting on it, pulls a Shepard and says "we'll bang, okay." Then goes to the island where he just repeats it over and over to the island girls.
 

Pixillin'

Active Member
Oct 8, 2024
745
708
Except he's not in any military being trained. He's a self taught adventurer that comes with all of the bad habits of being self taught. He have been dead long ago if not for his mentor and his powers. Diana should have been a humbling experience but like Mav said, actual character growth gets in the way when you've got women to collect. I know that last part doesn't apply to you, Pix, but it needs to be said all the same.

He barely eeks out a victory against Diana and instead of reflecting on it, pulls a Shepard and says "we'll bang, okay." Then goes to the island where he just repeats it over and over to the island girls.
Except that he's not really self taught, Eliza's dad was supposed to be the one training him and was supposed to be pretty good. We don't have full details but we know he had at least one fight with goblins (though it looks like it might not have gone well for him). At any rate, training is what the 10 year absence was supposed to be about - well training and hiding. So he should have about as much training as Diana - just not with his powers, those are relatively new.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Harem4life

jadepaladin

Well-Known Member
Mar 9, 2020
1,226
2,485
Except that he's not really self taught, Eliza's dad was supposed to be the one training him and was supposed to be pretty good. We don't have full details but we know he had at least one fight with goblins (though it looks like it might not have gone well for him). At any rate, training is what the 10 year absence was supposed to be about - well training and hiding. So he should have about as much training as Diana - just not with his powers, those are relatively new.
I think we interpreted the story differently, and that's fine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pixillin'

storm1051787

Active Member
Mar 23, 2019
770
1,175
Except he's not in any military being trained. He's a self taught adventurer that comes with all of the bad habits of being self taught. He have been dead long ago if not for his mentor and his powers. Diana should have been a humbling experience but like Mav said, actual character growth gets in the way when you've got women to collect. I know that last part doesn't apply to you, Pix, but it needs to be said all the same.

He barely eeks out a victory against Diana and instead of reflecting on it, pulls a Shepard and says "we'll bang, okay." Then goes to the island where he just repeats it over and over to the island girls.

He's not self taught He was trained by a former knight and by an order of assassins. He had actual mentors and teachers for most of those 10 years and only became on his own right before the story started.


And he didn't eek out a victory over Diana at all. He lost straight up, he even admits it himself that she's stronger than he is. He lost round 1. Manages to recover and get back in the fight become of his regen abilities, loses round 2 and gets back in the fight for the same reason, then there is a double knock out in round 3.That's two loses and 1 draw.


I don't really get why people are making a big deal out of the Diana thing though, he's not a normal Human and she's not a normal human. Mc has more potential, but she's had better training and more experience.
 

Pixillin'

Active Member
Oct 8, 2024
745
708
He's not self taught He was trained by a former knight and by an order of assassins. He had actual mentors and teachers for most of those 10 years and only became on his own right before the story started.


And he didn't eek out a victory over Diana at all. He lost straight up, he even admits it himself that she's stronger than he is. He lost round 1. Manages to recover and get back in the fight become of his regen abilities, loses round 2 and gets back in the fight for the same reason, then there is a double knock out in round 3.That's two loses and 1 draw.


I don't really get why people are making a big deal out of the Diana thing though, he's not a normal Human and she's not a normal human. Mc has more potential, but she's had better training and more experience.
I don't really care. MC's powers are good enough most of the time and growing. I hope to finish this little island vacation, get back to port, say goodbye to Diana and the Pirate Twins (ideally forever) and then get back to the story. If it was up to me, I wouldn't have gotten into a fight with Diana in the first place, there was nothing to fight about.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,503
19,065
I don't really care. MC's powers are good enough most of the time and growing. I hope to finish this little island vacation, get back to port, say goodbye to Diana and the Pirate Twins (ideally forever) and then get back to the story. If it was up to me, I wouldn't have gotten into a fight with Diana in the first place, there was nothing to fight about.
Expect Diana is the one that started the fight so you would have to defend yourself. Now if you got what you wanted you would of never left so you would never even would of met Diana.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pixillin'

Pixillin'

Active Member
Oct 8, 2024
745
708
Expect Diana is the one that started the fight so you would have to defend yourself. Now if you got what you wanted you would of never left so you would never even would of met Diana.
That's true, which would have been excellent but she didn't *really* start the fight. The MC got in her way and after she asked him several times, refused to let her do her job. It's not like she just attacked him out of the blue.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,503
19,065
That's true, which would have been excellent but she didn't *really* start the fight. The MC got in her way and after she asked him several times, refused to let her do her job. It's not like she just attacked him out of the blue.
Now this is if I remember the scene correctly only seen it once so I could be way wrong.

maybe but I see her as the attacker as she was the aggressor in my eyes. I don't think she even really gave the MC much chance to talk as far as I can recall. If I recall correctly when she found out he knew the pirates and was trying to get her to let them go and was working for the Kingdom she branded him as traitor and attacked.

Like yeah from her pov I can see why she would attack but I still see her being the hostile one not really allowing the MC proper chance to explain or talk very much. As to me I don't see the MC being much of a threat her at that point to warrant a attack even if she considers him a traitor. But I am a little biased as one thing I hate in games or whatever is when a character attacks over an assumption without letting someone explain fully unless you know that character is meant to be a bad guy / evil or just an asshole .
 

Pixillin'

Active Member
Oct 8, 2024
745
708
Now this is if I remember the scene correctly only seen it once so I could be way wrong.

maybe but I see her as the attacker as she was the aggressor in my eyes. I don't think she even really gave the MC much chance to talk as far as I can recall. If I recall correctly when she found out he knew the pirates and was trying to get her to let them go and was working for the Kingdom she branded him as traitor and attacked.

Like yeah from her pov I can see why she would attack but I still see her being the hostile one not really allowing the MC proper chance to explain or talk very much. As to me I don't see the MC being much of a threat her at that point to warrant a attack even if she considers him a traitor. But I am a little biased as one thing I hate in games or whatever is when a character attacks over an assumption without letting someone explain fully unless you know that character is meant to be a bad guy / evil or just an asshole .
I could be wrong to. I only played it once, the day it came out but IIRC she asked him several times - with increasing levels of anger - to stand aside. From my POV, she took the first swing but it was MC's fault because she warned him that she wasn't having it.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,503
19,065
So I just replayed that part again to be sure but Diana attacked first. Mc shows and stops her from killing Kira and Pearl and then Diana attacks the mc for defending the pirates.
so in other words Pix would of let it happen while most other players wouldn't
 

Pixillin'

Active Member
Oct 8, 2024
745
708
so in other words Pix would of let it happen while most other players wouldn't
I wouldn't have gone in the first place - I would have saved her the trouble after my previous experience with them - but that doesn't make it not MC's fault. If a soldier shows up to kill some people and you side with the people she's trying to kill, it's still your fault you got attacked.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,503
19,065
I wouldn't have gone in the first place - I would have saved her the trouble after my previous experience with them - but that doesn't make it not MC's fault. If a soldier shows up to kill some people and you side with the people she's trying to kill, it's still your fault you got attacked.
I generally agree expect the MC is a personal bodyguard to the princess and is trusted by the King. So at the very least I think she can hear him out or verify his identity before making a rash decision that she can't undo.
 

Pixillin'

Active Member
Oct 8, 2024
745
708
I generally agree expect the MC is a personal bodyguard to the princess and is trusted by the King. So at the very least I think she can hear him out or verify his identity before making a rash decision that she can't undo.
Nah, if I were here I would have done my best to take him prisoner but I would have done what I came to do. I wouldn't call of a - apparently long planned and probably very expensive mission (given the number of people involved) because some rando dude says he knows the king.

Let's be honest, Pix's MC can't exist with Eliza so he would have never made it back in the day with Alice only.
with[out] Eliza.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,503
19,065
Nah, if I were here I would have done my best to take him prisoner but I would have done what I came to do. I wouldn't call of a - apparently long planned and probably very expensive mission (given the number of people involved) because some rando dude says he knows the king.
and if I were the king I would have her demoted when he finds out especially cause they have magic birds and device so would of not taken that long to check in. Cause from my POV she could at least keep them prisoner and wait to execute them especially if he might be an important person to the Kingdom.
 

storm1051787

Active Member
Mar 23, 2019
770
1,175
I could be wrong to. I only played it once, the day it came out but IIRC she asked him several times - with increasing levels of anger - to stand aside. From my POV, she took the first swing but it was MC's fault because she warned him that she wasn't having it.
Nope. Diana never asks him to stand aside, she really doesn't say much of anything. "Just how dare you attack the royal navy and defend these pirates"
I wouldn't have gone in the first place - I would have saved her the trouble after my previous experience with them - but that doesn't make it not MC's fault. If a soldier shows up to kill some people and you side with the people she's trying to kill, it's still your fault you got attacked.
I mean the mc didn't even know who she was at first. I don't really think he should have stood there while she kills his friends(they're his friends even if you hate them), especially since their innocent and are really only getting attacked because of who their Dad is. Honestly, she really should be executing them in the first place, she should be taking them prisoner and having them stand trail. Or at least ask the king what he wants to do with them.
I generally agree expect the MC is a personal bodyguard to the princess and is trusted by the King. So at the very least I think she can hear him out or verify his identity before making a rash decision that she can't undo.
I mean to be fair they start fighting without introducing each other. Then when he does introduce himself she doesn't believe him because why would the princess's bodyguard be miles away from the capital defending pirates?
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,503
19,065
I mean to be fair they start fighting without introducing each other. Then when he does introduce himself she doesn't believe him because why would the princess's bodyguard be miles away from the capital defending pirates?
I get that I think with how fast the MC got news of the girls needing help she could of waited if they have magic devices and ways to verify pretty quickly. But the MC would have to be willing to be a prisoner till she can verify. But I kind of forgot they were fighting first
 

Pixillin'

Active Member
Oct 8, 2024
745
708
and if I were the king I would have her demoted when he finds out especially cause they have magic birds and device so would of not taken that long to check in. Cause from my POV she could at least keep them prisoner and wait to execute them especially if he might be an important person to the Kingdom.
For her it was very personal though. I don't think the possibility of demotion would stop her, or that she'd even think about it in that moment - since the whole reason she became a sailor in the first place was to do what she's about to do. (From my POV it almost would have been worth that big run across the water to watch - almost, but not quite.)
 

storm1051787

Active Member
Mar 23, 2019
770
1,175
I get that I think with how fast the MC got news of the girls needing help she could of waited if they have magic devices and ways to verify pretty quickly. But the MC would have to be willing to be a prisoner till she can verify.
The girls sent a magic raven, and even then the communication wasn't instant. It would seem really weird to stop a fight to verify his identity and even if he was telling the truth it's not like the mc has any authority here. He's not there on behalf of the king or the princess, it's purely personal business. She is there on behalf of the king though. If anything the king might be upset with the mc for hindering his admiral on official business. I don't think either the mc or Diana was wrong in the situation other than the fact Diana wanted to kill the twins in the first place instead of just taking them prisoner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maviarab
4.00 star(s) 90 Votes